Key Programs

Humboldt Port Development

Industrial Forest Lands

National Forest Conservation

Clean Water

Biodiversity Protection

Other Projects

Contact Us

P. O. Box 397
Garberville, CA 95542

ph: (707) 923-2931
fax: (707) 923-4210

submit comments

      
Home >> EPIC Cases >> Cases filed - 1997 to the present >>

Point Source Litigation
EPIC v. Pacific Lumber Company and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

Date Filed: July 21, 2001

This case involves the hundreds of pipes, ditches, culverts, and other sources that emit pollution into the Bear Creek watershed. Under the Federal Clean Water Act (CWA), it is illegal to discharge pollution into the waters of the United States from such "discrete conveyance points" unless it is covered by a permit under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES). EPIC filed a complaint on July 24, 2001 to compel Pacific Lumber to obtain NPDES permits for discharges from such points, and we submitted a motion for a preliminary injunction on July 31. Pacific Lumber submitted a motion to dismiss the case in August 2001. We filed a motion for a temporary restraining order (TRO), and the hearing on the motion was held on August 13 with the judge ruling against us. On September 25, 2001 we submitted our opposition to Pacific Lumber's motion to dismiss and an amended complaint that adds the EPA as a defendant to the lawsuit and additional claims that challenge the relevant regulations. Pacific Lumber's motion to dismiss was withdrawn in October 2001.

EPIC is represented in this case by Michael Lozeau and the Stanford University Law Clinic of Earthjustice Legal Defense Fund.


More Information
  • EPIC Water Case Moves Ahead: Federal Court Reins in Logging Pollution (December 1, 2003)
    On October 14, a federal court issued a momentous decision in a lawsuit that EPIC filed against Maxxam/Pacific Lumber in 2001, ruling that pollution from logging is not exempt from the Clean Water Act. The ...
  • Federal Court Reins In Logging Pollution (October 15, 2003)
    Water Pollution from Logging Operations Will Require Federal Permits
    San Francisco--Late yesterday, October 14, a federal court ruled that logging companies are no different from anyone else and must abide by the Clean Water Act. The opinion by Judge Marilyn Hall Patel finds ...

  • EPIC is challenging Maxxam/Pacific Lumber under the federal Clean Water Act, charging that it is illegally discharging sediment and herbicides from ditches, culverts, and other "point sources."


View a printer friendly version of this page
Return to Cases filed - 1997 to the present
 
Other pages in Cases filed - 1997 to the present